Hank Elsner Live Wire
Tech, crypto and space news, read live while the laser runs. · RSS
Home / Deep Dive · · By Hank Elsner · about 4 min read aloud

How a Stock Market Crash Gets Stopped: Circuit Breakers Explained

After the worst single day in market history, Wall Street built emergency brakes. Here is exactly when they trip, what happens next, and the day the market lost a trillion dollars in minutes.

How a Stock Market Crash Gets Stopped: Circuit Breakers Explained

On one Monday in October 1987, the stock market fell more than 22 percent. In one day. Imagine your retirement account losing almost a quarter of its value between breakfast and dinner. That day changed how the market works, and tonight I'll show you the brakes it left behind.

Black Monday

October 19, 1987. The Dow Jones Industrial Average dropped about 22.6 percent. It's still the biggest one-day percentage drop in the Dow's history.

A big part of what made it so bad was a feedback loop. Prices fall, so automated selling programs sell. That pushes prices lower, so more programs sell. Nobody could step in fast enough to stop it, because there was no pause button.

After that, regulators said: we need a pause button.

The circuit breakers

Today the U.S. stock market has three levels of what are called market-wide circuit breakers. They're based on how far the S&P 500 has fallen from the previous day's close.

Level one: a 7 percent drop. Trading across the whole market stops for 15 minutes.

Level two: a 13 percent drop. Another 15-minute pause.

Level three: a 20 percent drop. Trading stops for the rest of the day. Everybody goes home.

There's one detail on the first two levels. If the drop happens late in the day, after 3:25 in the afternoon Eastern, levels one and two don't stop trading. Only level three does.

Why a pause helps

Why does fifteen minutes help? Because panic is fast and thinking is slow. A pause gives people time to look at what's actually happening, check the news, and realize maybe the world isn't ending. It breaks the feedback loop. It's like the market taking a deep breath.

The day the market lost a trillion dollars in minutes

Now fast forward to May 6, 2010. In the afternoon, out of nowhere, the Dow dropped nearly a thousand points in a matter of minutes. Some big, famous company stocks briefly traded for a penny. Others spiked to absurd prices. And then, almost as fast, most of it came back.

It's called the Flash Crash. Roughly a trillion dollars of market value vanished and mostly reappeared in under an hour. Investigators later pointed to a huge automated sell order and lightning-fast trading programs pulling back all at once. Computers trading with computers, faster than any human could follow.

Brakes for single stocks

That crash led to a second kind of brake, for individual stocks. It's called limit up, limit down. Each stock gets a price band around where it's been trading recently. If it moves outside that band too fast, trading in that one stock pauses for a few minutes.

So now there are brakes for the whole market, and brakes for each stock.

Have they actually been used?

Yes. In March 2020, when COVID hit, the level one breaker tripped four times in about two weeks. Four times, trading across the entire market just stopped for 15 minutes, because the S&P 500 had fallen 7 percent that day. People who lived through that remember watching the screens freeze.

Why this matters this week

Remember tonight's market news? Three straight down days, Nvidia reporting, a giant IPO on Thursday. And the Fed governor who warned about AI causing herd trading, where a lot of automated systems all run for the same door at once.

That warning is basically a description of 1987 and 2010. The brakes are there for exactly that. They don't stop prices from falling. They just stop them from falling faster than people can think.

I'm not your financial advisor. But knowing the brakes exist is a good reason not to panic if you ever see the screens freeze.

Ask the chatWere you around for March 2020? Did you watch the market freeze? Type YES or TOO YOUNG.
On the laserEngraving "Level 1: 7%. Breathe." on a card. For the best "I panic-sold" story in chat.