Hank Elsner Live Wire
Tech, crypto and space news, read live while the laser runs. · RSS
Home / Deep Dive · · By Hank Elsner · about 4 min read aloud

Why Catching a Rocket Changes Everything

For sixty years we threw away a machine worth tens of millions of dollars every launch. Here is how landing them, and now catching them, rewrites the math of space.

Why Catching a Rocket Changes Everything

Imagine flying from Texas to New York, landing, and then throwing the airplane away. Every flight. Brand new plane, every single time. That's how we did spaceflight for about sixty years.

The throwaway era

From the first satellites to the Space Shuttle era, almost every rocket was used once. The engines, the fuel tanks, the computers, all of it fell into the ocean or burned up on the way down. The Shuttle reused the orbiter and its boosters, but refurbishing them between flights was so slow and expensive that it never got cheap.

Here's what surprises people. The fuel isn't the expensive part. Rocket fuel for a big launch costs a small fraction of the price of the rocket. The expensive part is the hardware. And we were throwing it away.

The first landing

December 21, 2015. Cape Canaveral, Florida. A Falcon 9 rocket launches satellites, and then its first stage, the big lower part, turns around, fires its engines to slow down, and comes back. It drops out of the night sky on a column of fire, unfolds its legs and lands upright on a pad. The people in the control room lost their minds.

It wasn't the first time anyone had landed a rocket, but it was the first time an orbital-class booster flew a real mission to orbit and came back to land. Since then, Falcon 9 boosters have landed hundreds of times, and some individual boosters have flown more than twenty missions.

How do you land a rocket?

Try balancing a broomstick upright on your palm. You have to keep moving your hand under it. Now imagine the broomstick is falling from the edge of space, at several times the speed of sound, and your hand is a rocket engine. That's the problem.

The booster flips around, fires its engines to slow down, steers with grid fins, those waffle-shaped panels near the top, and at the very end fires again to slow to almost nothing right at the moment it touches the ground. Computers make thousands of tiny corrections every second. There's no pilot.

Then they decided legs were too heavy

For Starship, SpaceX went further. Legs are heavy. Every pound of landing legs is a pound you can't carry to orbit. So they asked: what if the rocket doesn't land at all? What if the tower catches it?

The launch tower has two giant arms, nicknamed the chopsticks. On October 13, 2024, a Super Heavy booster came back from launch, slowed down, and slid in between those arms, and they closed on it. Caught, in midair.

And now, this month, they did it with the ship itself, the upper stage, coming back from a full trip around the Earth. That's the piece that's even harder to recover, because it's coming in from orbit, hitting the atmosphere at enormous speed, and has to survive the heat.

Why it matters

So why does any of this matter to you? Follow the chain.

Reusable rockets make launches cheaper. Cheaper launches mean more satellites. More satellites mean things like internet from space for rural areas and ships at sea, and better weather data. Way cheaper launches mean you can start thinking about things that used to be fantasy. Big space stations. Bases on the moon. Ships to Mars.

And remember why NASA cheered this week. NASA is paying for Starship to land astronauts on the moon. The whole plan depends on refueling ships in orbit, over and over, and you can only do that affordably if the ships come back.

What it's like to watch

If you've never watched one of these live, do it. SpaceX streams them. Watch the booster come back. It looks fake the first time. It looks like a video played backwards. And then you realize somebody built a machine that does that, on purpose, over and over.

Ask the chatWould you trust a rocket that's already flown 20 times? More or less than a brand new one? Type MORE or LESS.
On the laserEngraving "Caught, not crashed." on a card. For the best answer on why a used rocket might be safer.